EPA-94-HA12-03-A013

094

4,100 千元

2005/03/16

2005/12/31

寰瀛法律事務所李元德

回收基管會

寰瀛法律事務所 方敏慈

科技計畫

回收清除處理費、訴願、行政訴訟

Recycling and Disposal Management Fee、

寰瀛法律事務所 方敏慈

23705888分機3314

mintzu@mail.fblaw.com.tw

本計畫之執行方式為辦理責任業者管理、稽查或相關作業之行政救濟案件答辯、移送行政執行、涉及刑責移送偵查案件與涉訟案件、提供法律諮詢、提供修法建議等。 執行期間完成訴願答辯６件、行政訴訟答辯１０件、回覆法律諮詢１０件、辦理移送行政執行作業６１件、提出廢棄物清理法第１６條及第２０條之罰鍰額度裁量標準並舉行２次的法令研習。 分析訴願案件及法律諮詢的案件，得知　貴署針對責任業者所作成之行政處分遇有相對人提起訴願者，相較於９２年度減少了７０％，顯示 貴署作成處分之過程日趨嚴謹。法律諮詢案件之件數依比例僅為９３年度諮詢件數之２０％，問題也漸具深度。行政執行案件，遭退件比例為０，而累計歷年迄今追討的金額統計已逾新台幣２億４００萬元。 末，由上開工作成果及兩次的法令研習與 貴署同仁的接觸可知，本計畫確實已達成完成責任業者應繳納回收清除處理費追繳、妥善處理依廢棄物清理法及相關法規辦理責任業者違法案件、運用外在法律專業資源，提昇稽查相關作業之成效等目標。

回收清除處理費、訴願、行政訴訟

EPA-94-HA12-03-A013.pdf

6MB

[期末報告]公開完整版

2006/4/1 上午 12:00:00

The methods to execute this project include defending cases with regard to the management, inspection or other related matters of the Responsible Proprietors in administrative remedy proceedings, applying for administrative enforcement, reporting cases involving criminal conduct to the authority for investigation, providing legal consultation and offering suggestion for amendments of laws. The Executor’s accomplishments during the Project Term include defense in 6 cases during administrative appeal proceedings, defense in 10 cases of administrative litigation, 10 cases of providing legal consultation and 61 cases concerning the application for administrative enforcement to the responsible proprietors failing to pay fees. In addition, we have further provided the discretionary standards determining the fines specified in Article 16 and 20 of Waste Disposal Act and twice held legal seminars. By analyzing the cases of administrative appeal and legal consultation, it is learned that the cases in which the Responsible Proprietors appealed to the administrative remedy procedure against the administrative actions rendered by EPA have decreased in the percentage of 70% in comparison with the cases in 2003, showing that the procedure of rendering an administrative action in EPA has gradually become more and more strict and cautious. In addition, the number of cases of legal consultation have simply been 20% of that of the cases in 2004, and the complexity and comprehensiveness of the questions have been increased as well. The cases of administrative enforcement being reversed were zero, and the amount of pursuit accumulated until now has been more than 204,000,000 NTD. In view of the abovementioned accomplishments, the ultimate purposes of this project have indeed been achieved, including the pursuit of recycle and disposal management fee from the Responsible Proprietors.

Recycling and Disposal Management Fee、