環境資源報告成果查詢系統

評估室內空氣品質之影響因子及檢測技術暨增修室內空氣品質標準

中文摘要   本研究團隊於103年度行政院環保署專題委託研究計畫「評估室內空氣品質之影響因子及檢測技術暨增修室內空氣品質標準」共分為四個部分,各章節計畫執行狀況與成果分別敘述如下:   為釐清室內外人為活動與使用行為對於室內空氣品質之影響,本團隊利用自1998年以來累計共764筆不同建築物之實場監測資料,將其整合相對應時間之環保署大氣汙染物一般空氣測站監測資料,及場所建築特徵和室內外潛在污染源之問卷調查資訊,並使用描述性統計、相關性評估、變異數分析與GEE模型等以統計方法進行室內空氣汙染物的影響因子與其貢獻性之分析。透過文獻歸納IAQ的惡化會使得室內人員有頭痛、呼吸道感染、哮喘、過敏、注意力不佳、病態建築症候群等症狀出現,因此仍應重視各類型場所之IAQ。經分析後發現場所流動配置與環境、室內設備或傢俱、使用空調類型與機房環境維護和室內外潛在污染源等皆會影響IAQ,然於各類場所中影響因子與受影響之空氣汙染物及影響程度皆不太相同。本研究利用學界罕見之寶貴資料,首次整合長達15年不同類型建築物之室內監測數據,釐清影響室內各式空氣汙染物濃度的因素,進而評估室內外人為活動與使用行為對室內空氣品質的影響及影響程度。   在完成微粒公告與非公告之監測值的比對後,本研究建議建立PM2.5與PM10的PEM採樣器和公告方法監測值之相關性,可使PM2.5與PM10的PEM採樣器被應用在評估實場PM2.5與PM10濃度。在綜合室內懸浮微粒組成調查、健康風險評估和統合分析,研究發現:(1) 室內空氣中的PM2.5以鋁、鈣、鎂、鐵和鉀等無機元素,硫酸鹽等鹽類和有機碳為主要的組成,(2) 地殼元素及透過光化反應生成的二次氣膠為室內PM2.5的主要貢獻源,(3) 有必要需透過更多的實驗數據深入探討本土各類型公共場所空氣中的碳種類及其濃度,並分析其濃度和健康效應的關係,以完整評估訂定室內PM2.5中的碳標準值的必要性。 本研究於國內10處室內公共場所(補習班及電影院)進行半揮發性有機化合物(以鄰苯二甲酸酯PAEs與萘等PAHs)於氣態、懸浮微粒(PM2.5)、懸浮微粒(PM10)、地板灰塵採樣及分析。PAHs結果顯示,補習班與電影院各採樣點氣相總PAHs濃度均高於固相(PM2.5 & PM10)總PAHs,其中氣相PAHs中以萘之濃度最高並遠高於固相濃度,補習班與電影院空氣中萘濃度(氣態及懸浮微粒)之平均值與標準差(MeanSD)分別為(336383 ng/m3)及(8941333 ng/m3)。補習班與電影院空氣PM中PAHs以2-3環較多,5環以上之PAHs較少。室內地板灰塵PAHs主要以3~4環及萘等常出現於此介質中。PAEs結果顯示氣相PAEs方面,分子量較低(<300 g/mol)揮發性較高之PAEs如DEP、DIBP、及DBP濃度大部分均有測出。PM中PAEs濃度較集中於分子量300-400 g/mol之間。室內地板灰塵中DIBP、DBP、DEHP、DNOP、DINP與DIDP檢出率高達100%。PAEs暴露評估結果顯示,研究中主要公共場所PAEs暴露量,無論成年人或兒童,其各類PAEs不同暴露途徑(食入、吸入與皮膚接觸)之總暴露量均低於歐盟建立之耐受量。公共場所內PAEs普遍分布於空氣與灰塵中,燃燒加熱來源為PAHs主要來源,建議未來於更多室內場所評估新興污染物於室內環境多介質分布及釐清污染來源,為日後訂定室內環境標準之依據。   為探討培養法與qPCR對於檢測室內真菌暴露之相關性,本研究分析了同一教學研究大樓的8個教學辦公空間之空氣中真菌,結果發現2種方法真菌檢測值呈現顯著正相關 (r = 0.766);且7家補習班之空氣樣本合併結果亦呈現此2種方法測值為高度正相關 (r = 0.937);然若合併補習班與教學研究大樓之數據,甚至加入影城數據,則2方法測值便無相關性 (P > 0.05)。此證明了培養法與qPCR監測結果之相關性受到場所特性影響,若相同類型之場所,2方法對於真菌檢測值相關性極佳。另外,本研究亦藉由分析南部一光電廠7個辦公空間中真菌污染情形與31位員工健康效應之關聯性以評估不同真菌暴露指標 (可培養性真菌/總真菌、空氣/灰塵、總體真菌/真菌種類) 之應用性。空氣中可培養性Paecilomyces濃度越高,則適應性負荷_心血管及呼吸道積分越高;空氣中的可培養性Fusarium及灰塵中A. versicolor與Aspergillus/Penicillium/Paecilomyces varioti濃度則與FVC%顯著負相關;而受試者之生活品值總積分與空氣中可培養性Yeast和總真菌的濃度承顯著負相關。由此結果初步可知,室內真菌污染確實會造成不良之健康效應、降低生活品質,但不同真菌指標所對應的健康性應不盡相同,尚無法歸納出何種指標對於評估健康危害之應用性較佳;再者,特定真菌菌種/屬似乎較真菌總體對健康的影響性更明顯,然由於目前樣本數仍少,未來仍需累積更多之研究人數才能獲得更清楚之結論。
中文關鍵字 室內空氣品質、揮發性/半揮發性有機物、真/細菌、懸浮微粒

基本資訊

專案計畫編號 EPA-103-FA11-03-A083 經費年度 103 計畫經費 3420 千元
專案開始日期 2014/01/24 專案結束日期 2014/12/31 專案主持人 蘇慧貞
主辦單位 空保處 承辦人 陳樺蓁 執行單位 國立成功大學

成果下載

類型 檔名 檔案大小 說明
期末報告 EPA103FA1103A083(公開版).pdf 0MB

Assessment on the revision of impact factors, sampling technologies and standards of indoor air qual

英文摘要   The topic of EPA project in 2014 is "Assessment on the revision of impact factors, sampling technologies and standards of indoor air quality." It is divided into four parts that the project implementation status and results of each chapter are described as follows:   This study is aimed to integrate the database of indoor air indicators and pollutants established by our research team over the past 15 years to evaluate indoor activities, outdoor activities and usage behavior impacts on indoor air quality (IAQ) in Taiwan. Since 1998, we have continuously collected monitoring data of IAQ in a total of 764 buildings in different indoor environments. We further integrated the profiles of ambient pollutants from EPA atmospheric stations according to the sampling area and specific time. Building characteristics and potential indoor and outdoor sources were summarized as well. We used descriptive statistics, correlation analysis, Kruskal-Wallis test and Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE) to evaluate the impacts of indoor activities, outdoor activities and usage behavior on IAQ. The deterioration of IAQ would make people have headaches, respiratory infections, asthma, allergies, poor attention and sick building syndrome by literature review. Therefore, we still need to pay attention to IAQ in different types of places. After the data analysis, we found that all of the spaces flow/configuration and environment, indoor equipment or furniture, types and environment maintenance of air conditioner and potential sources from indoor or outdoor would affect IAQ, but the affected air pollutants and influence degree of impact factors are inconsistent in different types of places. In conclusion, our study is the first to evidence a series of impacts of ambient pollutants and climate variations on indoor air pollutants by using a 15-years dataset of field investigations. We have clarified the indoor activities, outdoor activities and usage behavior contributing to the change of levels of indoor air pollutants in different places.   This study has also conducted a comparison between data of non-standard sampling methods and standard sampling method for PM2.5 and PM10. We suggest that build the relationship between the levels of PM2.5 and PM10 personal environment monitoring (PEM) instrument and standard sampling methods, PM2.5 and PM10 PEM instrument could be used to monitor the levels of PM2.5 in the fields. According to these results of compositions of indoor PM2.5, meta-analysis and risk assessment, this study found: (1) Al, Ca, Mg, Fe and K, SO4-2 and organic carbon are predominant compositions of indoor PM2.5, (2) soil and photochemical reactions are important contributors of indoor PM2.5 and (3) it needs more evidences in the correlation between indoor carbon level and health effects in the future, to assess whether set indoor carbon standard values.   In this study, indoor semi-volatile compounds (including PAEs and PAHs) partitioning between the gas, particle (PM2.5 and PM10) and settled dust were investigated in ten public places (7 cram schools and 3 theaters). Results showed that the levels of gaseous PAHs were higher than that for particulate PAHs in all sampling sites. Gaseous PAHs were dominated by naphthalene, which exists almost entirely in the gas phase. The average air concentrations (gas- and particle phase) of naphthalene in cram schools and movie theaters were 336383 ng/m3 and 8941333 ng/m3, respectively. Two- and three-ring PAHs accounted for most of the air PAHs in cram schools and theaters, while PAHs in the dust samples were dominated by two- to four-ring PAHs. Lower molecular weight PAEs such as DEP, DIBP and DBP were frequently detected in the gas phase, while the PAEs with molecular weight between 300 to 400 g/ mol. were more abundant in the particle phase. The detection rates for DIBP, DBP, DEHP, DNOP, DINP and DIDP were reached to 100% in all indoor dust samples. The daily intakes (ingestion, inhalation and skin contact) of the target phthalates for adult and children were estimated lower than TDIs of the EU-CSTEE. More research regarding the distributions of SVOCs indoors is needed for the establishment of indoor air standards for those emerging compounds.   This study evaluated the association between the fungal concentrations quantified by real-time quantitative (qPCR) and culture assays by analyzing the air samples taken from eight spaces of a teaching and research building and seven after-class schools. For the teaching and research building, the total fungal levels were positively and significantly correlated with culturable fungal concentrations (r = 0.766, P < 0.05). Also, the results of after-class schools showed an extremely high correlation between the levels of total and culturable fungi (r = 0.937, P < 0.05). However, such significant relationship between culture and qPCR assays were no longer present if the data collected from sampling locations with varied characteristics were pooled to analyze (P > 0.05). Our findings demonstrate that the characteristics of location would affect the association between the fungal contamination determined by qPCR and culture assays, i.e. positive correlation would be observed in the locations having similar characteristics. Additionally, in order to investigate the applicability of the indicators commonly used for assessing fungal contamination, this study evaluate the impacts of fungal contamination on human health. Seven offices and 31 workers of a photonic fabrication factory located in Southern Taiwan were included, and various indicators of fungal contamination (culturable/total fungi, dustborne/airborne fungi, fungi/specific fungal genus or species) were used. The results show a positive relationship between the levels of culturable airborne Paecilomyces and allostatic load sore in respiratory/cardiovascular systems. Besides, more culturable Fusarium in the indoor air and dustboren Aspergillus versicolor and Aspergillus/Penicillium/ Paecilomyces varioti would result in the significant decrease of FVC% (Betaadj = -0.366 to -0.467, P < 0.05). For quality of life, the greater levels of airborne total fungi and culturable Yeast were associated with lower life quality index score. Based on these preliminary results, we demonstrate the adverse effects of the indoor fungal contamination on human health and quality of life; however, the question of which indicator is better for evaluating indoor fungal pollution relating to human health still cannot be concluded. Moreover, the specific fungal genus/species seems to influence health outcomes more obvious than “Fungi”; nevertheless, we still need more samples to further clarify this inference.
英文關鍵字 Indoor Air Quality、Volatile/Semi-Volatile Organic Compounds、Fungi/Bacteria、Particulate Matter