環境資源報告成果查詢系統

現行環境法律執行制度之檢討及改善措施

中文摘要 現行環境執行制度,大部分定性為委辦事項,地方執法,環保署有監督權,堪稱妥當。地方環保局有三分之二的執行人力,但只告發20%的案件,80%係由環保署督察大隊完成,督察大隊之告發權乃有必要維持。鄉鎮市公所短期內難被進一步賦予執行的職掌。公權力行使之委託私人執行,短期仍不宜,但中長期則可為審慎之考量。行政助手宜廣泛引用。行政機關於罰鍰處分作成前,原則上應予相對人陳述意見的機會。舉證責任之分配,事涉基本人權,所造成行政機關的負荷,須以相關人力與設備之充分為因應。「重金屬污染源事業污染管制大執法行動專案執行計畫作業要點」,係有現行法之依據,施行以來頗收成效。議員之關說背後存有複雜的政經與選制原因,處理不易。未來,宜考慮參照歐盟立法明定官方有適度公開業者資訊的義務,也得考慮對獲得ISO14000認證並願意進行社區公開或社區參與監督的業者,酌予減輕稽核。有關環保事項的中央/地方權限劃分,執行權主要劃交直轄市與縣市,有合理性。未來若直轄市、縣市行政區域大幅合併,例如直轄市、縣市合併成為六個而已,再如合併一至三個鄉鎮市為一個,則必須檢討權限劃分。就罰鍰之收取,未來宜針對效率效能為必要之修法。
中文關鍵字 執行,行政程序法,地方制度法

基本資訊

專案計畫編號 EPA-91-K101-02-206 經費年度 091 計畫經費 570 千元
專案開始日期 2002/03/11 專案結束日期 2002/11/30 專案主持人 黃錦堂
主辦單位 管考處 承辦人 執行單位 國立台灣大學

成果下載

類型 檔名 檔案大小 說明
期末報告 0000029550.pdf 0MB [期末報告]公開完整版

Review of the structure and measures of the enforcement of environmental laws in Taiwan

英文摘要 This paper examines the monitoring and enforcement of environmental regulations, including the issue of decentralization of enforcement powers, the legal restraints of adjudication, especially about civil penalty and discretionary power, and the reinventing of enforcement system. This paper finds out the following:the environmental affairs are correctly defined as statewide affairs; the enforcement powers are correctly delegated to county government while the EPA posses the monitory competence the civil penalty against incompliance must be carried out in accordance to the administrative procedure act. The administrative execution, especially the compulsion must abide by strictly the legal requests. The delegation of enforcement power to private persons, although advocated by some scholars, should not be adopted in the short run, while environmental volunteers (for example as monitors) should be enlarged. Looking forward, the freedom of environmental information act, such as those in Germany, should be adopted, so as the public could know the content of factories in the neighborhood or state wide, and so that they will be enabled to inspect. Factories obtaining ISO14000 should be given the chance to cooperate with the neighborhood to monitor, and in this way the environmental authorities will lessen the supervision. In case of great scale of reorganization of local government in Taiwan, the intergovernmental division of enforcement and monitoring powers should be reconsidered.
英文關鍵字 monitoring and enforcement,command and control